The Old and the Young by Carole Swingler

I think this is wonderful, Carole - and I do like the idea of showing the stages of the flower. It makes a stunning image left just on white paper.

This is a beautiful botanical study Carole and, as Thea has said, really stands out on the white paper.

Particularly like the "old" rose, not easy to get right either but you have made a great job of it. Lovely composition.

Clever one Carole you moving into higher levels all the time Carole

Another beautiful painting

Thank you very much all.

You've done a fantastic job with this Carole, nothing wrong with the young rose that I can see. It's a gorgeous piece - clear, luminous, a lovely contrast of sharpness and soft edges.

A very interesting idea Carole and painted beautifully. The "old" is more interesting- as with everything😉

Very kind if you Seok thank you. Marjorie I quite agree, that was my mind exactly!

Very emotional and meaningful Carole

Stunning work as always Carole, you've even managed to turn a dying rose into a thing of beauty.

If I could paint like that I would be very happy, Carole! This is soooo beautiful!

Lovely, lovely roses!

Beautifully delicate Carole

Thank you for your reassurance, you have made my day!

I agree with Val, another beauty.

A beautiful painting Carole

A gorgeous perfume too.! Just lovely Carole.

Thanks Fiona Russell and Jennifer, much appreciated.

Wonderfully simple. It gives an impact to these gorgeous flowers.

Thank you Beatrice really appreciate your comment as you are queen of roses!