2nd CHARCOAL PAINTING

Very lovely Charles, you are getting better, nice composition

Charles, is there anything you can't do?! Both your charcoal drawings are super. A lot of atmosphere, and great tone. Lovely indeed.

I told you to do another! I think this is much better, the light on the clearing floor stands out really well. I have done a few studies with charcoal and then painted watercolours from them - the charcoal study always seems better!

Striking image, lovely sense of light

Brilliant Charles!!

You've created a lovely 'mood' with this painting Charles, looking forward to seeing some more!

I like this too. I like the light on the background pines and the little clearing. Super composition.

Glad you used "proper" charcoal - it works so much better than stuff half-inched from the barbie.... You've made enormous progress in the space of just a couple of pictures.

Fantastic work in such a difficult medium. I needed hosing down when I tried working in charcoal!!

Congratulations Charles , Top ten gallery yet again, and richly deserved.

Well done Charles, you really deserve it, you charcoals paintings are fantastic

Well done, Charles, for making the Top Ten for September with your excellent charcoal work. Well deserved.

Huge congratulations on your gems making the Top Tens, Charles! Well deserved recognition of your fabulous pieces! Looking forward to many more!

Congratulations, Charles, for being in the September Top Ten. This is so well deserved!!!

Congratulations on your wonderful charcoal work in the September top ten, I'm not at all surprised! Thank-you for your very kind comment on my boat painting.