The worst advice on the internet?

Welcome to the forum.

Here you can discuss all things art with like-minded artists, join regular painting challenges, ask questions, buy and sell art materials and much more.

Make sure you sign in or register to join the discussions.

Hang on Studio Wall
Showing page 1 of 4
Message
The trouble with YouTube and similar platforms is that there's no quality control to speak of - in a way, that's one of their strengths, too - so you have to exercise your judgement.  Nowhere is this more true than of painting, and particularly oil painting.  Inevitably, the vaguely interested, the nervous beginner, the seeker after tips, will go on the net rather than buy books: because it's free; you can start and pause the videos; you can watch them at your convenience.  Will you go far wrong if you do?  Yes.  You could. This will not be another rant about Bob Ross - if you want to paint like him, there's nothing I can say to you - soul sold to the devil, another gullible grasper at what looks simple and immediate.  Or maybe, you just want to play with paint, and there's nothing wrong with that at all. It's more about people who have only recently learned to paint for themselves, and insist on passing their knowledge on: which so often resolves itself into a plug for Liquin and other easily-found, if expensive, products you "must have", or "need".  Liquin is all right: I have nothing against Liquin, though I could do without the smell.  Use it if you like.  But it's nonsense to say anyone needs it.  Low Odour Thinners, Sansodor, Turpentine, Zest-it, White Spirit - well the only one of those I'd say don't use is White Spirit, or at least the stuff you can buy in hardware stores.  It's hazardous (which doesn't bother me, really) and it just destroys paint (which does).  Real Turpentine is even more hazardous, but I'd use it for preference - it's rather better for the paint, because of its resinous nature. But again - you don't need any of those products, and your surroundings will smell sweeter, and you'll be healthier, if you don't use them.   But you can: of course you can; many do, but you don't HAVE to.   Stretched canvas is always recommended: well, it has its uses, but it never was an ideal surface for oil paint; and the cheap, thin cotton-duck canvases are certainly not the best.  What IS the best would take much more space to explain than I'm going to bore you with, but in short, it needs to be rigid, not flexible.  Ideally - plenty a good picture has been painted on cheap canvas, and I well understand its attraction.  But know there are alternatives.... you wouldn't, if you restricted yourself to certain YouTube (and other) sites. Varnish - I've just watched a video recommending W & N Gloss Varnish - it's good.  I use it, usually.  But the presenter didn't say don't use it immediately on completion - just that it would unify the painting and enhance colours.  Which it will.  It'll also crack and pull your paint off the board if you apply it too soon.   So having spent money you didn't need to spend on mediums and solvents - the idea of another video was that you should buy the cheapest paints you can (because they're "almost as good as the expensive brands": oh yes?  Really?) and  yet another suggests buying "value-pack" brushes - she recommends them because "I've always forgetting to clean mine, so it's not worth buying the more expensive ones" (but we're not all bone-idle, ducks - and don't want to keep throwing brushes away).  And what was the last one .... oh yes, always used tear-off palettes (because she also can't be bothered to clean her wooden one); and she holds up a tiny tear-off palette on which I could mix about two colours before needing an extra sheet.   Well; I meantersay - one could scream, could one not?  But I didn't.   Most of the advice outlined above is either wrong, or unnecessary.  I daresay it's well-meant, but you'll remember the lines about the Road to Hell and what it's paved with.  Far from making oil painting easier, it actually complicates it.  All you need with good quality paint is a minimal quantity of Linseed Oil, or perhaps Walnut Oil (more in the upper layers than the lower, as it doesn't make such a strong bond).  Good paint works without much medium, and often without any, if you first reduce it to the consistency you want with you palette knife, and of course if you've squeezed out enough to start with.  It doesn't really matter if you don't clean your palette every time - unless you like a clean, polished surface to work on: I'm the King of the Mucky Palette.  You do need enough space to work on (the Bob Ross palettes are actually very good in that respect!).  And the last absurdity - this one, I feel, takes any number of biscuits and follows it up with a plateful of sponge fingers: the point of buying "cadmium free" oil paints, and then using a hazardous solvent to break them down with, eludes me.  It is bonkers.  Cadmium and cobalt are heavy metals, but you're not going to hasten the end of the world by using them; companies which advertise cadmium-free paints, while continuing to flog hazardous solvents, aren't interested in your health - they're interested in their bottom-line, and in finding a marketing gimmick to fool the gullible.   There - I feel better for that!  Choose your advice with care - there is some good stuff on YouTube, and some complete rotten potatoes; and the same goes for the WetCanvas website, which has to contain more drivel per byte than just about any other.  
I’ve never yet found anything remotely useful on YouTube! Incessant and irrelevant rambling from so called ‘professional’ artists. I’m sure that there must be some good stuff amongst all this mundane dross, but I haven’t yet found any, although I very rarely look these days - perhaps its improved... Other people will have different views, but I’m no fan.  I’ll come back on some of your other comments Robert later perhaps, that’s a lot to digest in one go!

Edited
by Alan Bickley

You really do have to trawl on Youtube; there are gaziilions of "My top ten tips for....", "Avoid these mistakes...", and "What real professionals do that amateurs don't" (and despite all the claims it seems that getting up at 5:32 precisely, meditating until 6:23 precisely and then singing La Marseillaise whilst standing on my head drinking a bottle of Sol still isn't helping my art skillset). There is no script control, no quality control, little time spent in rehearsal, too much time-lapse with mindless gibbering accompaniment, too many "Ummmmmmmmmmm....." moments and any idiot can upload to Youtube. There are also some gems on Youtube. My sketches of Dopey (drawn whilst following a Disney artist who has an irritatingly whiny high-pitched voice) and Captain America (drawn following a fan-art guy who not only loves his stuff but talks to you like a human being) are amongst my most popular stuff on Instagram. We have the same problem in the music world - "This is how you play Eruption - Ta-daaaaaa". Nope, it's how "you" play Eruption, your notes are wrong in bars 6-9  and if you'd watched Eddie Van Halen you'd know he doesn't use that technique to achieve that sound at that point 
I've never looked on youtube for painting tips or advice. It is good for some things though... recently had a problem with our oil tank (oil central heating), and youtube saved us at least £700 by showing us how to fix it ourselves.
I don’t think you can just dismiss YouTube out of hand like that. You, personally, may not have found anything worthwhile but it doesn’t preclude anyone else’s search for that one snippet that resolves their problem. Yes, I agree there is a great deal of rubbish to sift through but just because you don’t use it doesn’t make it wrong. 
Ron - indeed.  I agree entirely with that - there IS good stuff on YouTube.  What troubles me a little is that people new to painting have no means of telling the good from the bad - so my advice would be to read a book or two (and actually BUY some dvd's from established artists) to give yourself a base of knowledge enabling you to say, of a particular presentation, 'that's just a pile of over-used knickers'.  And we don't want those, so we must discriminate.
For potential artists setting out on their artistic journey, it’s vital to start off with the right information. I agree with Robert here, there are some damn good books out there at the moment. And not forgetting Leisure Painter for the amateur painter, there’s loads of good advice and projects to give encouragement each month. I’ve yet to find anything of value on YouTube, but doubtless there is some, I just haven’t found it.
My pet hate on YouTube is the plethora of 'time-lapse' art videos. They don't teach anything. They just say, 'This is what I do!' at ridiculous speeds; accompanied by so called music; mostly just commercial 'jingles'! I have found that oil painting has to be approached from ground zero. If you can't take bonafide classes the next best bets are books that start with the basics. The authors are legion, well-known and their books easily obtainable. And YouTube it isn't any better with the other mediums! The better channels are evident by their straightforward approach, and long may the artists concerned prosper! John
I have linseed oil, stand oil, Sansador, turpentine and liquin. I have used Sanador, turpentine. I have used liquin for the first time today. Not all in the same pot. When I got the liquin, the linseed oil was next to it. I bought some. Why, you might ask, well at midnight if I'm painting, and even though I'm not that sure in what context to use it at the moment, I don't won't to be there without a medium. I want to be sure if I'm painting late and suddenly such would arise, I want to be ready to go. I prefer books but for something quick a glance at youtube is okay. There is so much stuff on there and you see things on the gallery that have been influenced or interpreted by something seen on youtube. Saying that, we all want to paint like our hero's, I'm still figuring out who that is but I certainly like the way the painted donkey's years ago. I don't like to watch to much stuff. I don't want to be influence to much by anyone. I like to pan out things as much as I can. I always ask for help when I'm struggling because somethings you can't do alone and you need the help of someone who has the knowledge and expertise in the field.
I use white spirit myself. For cleaning my brushes. AND FOR NOTHING ELSE! It does the job, pre-soaping, and it's cheaper than genuine turpentine, which we can also use for cleaning brushes; a somewhat expensive way of doing that job!  Odour less turps? My painting room (Can't call it a proper studio!) wouldn't feel the same without the smell of genuine turps! While I am here: Would you like to have a go at this view of the Cobb? It's my image, and you are welcome to try it; in any medium of course! Good Luck! John
That’s a great photo John. Not so sure in tempted, but it worth thinking about.
I'm doing a couple of things at the moment but I like your picture, I might give it a go in the next couple of weeks John.
Showing page 1 of 4