Minimal vase

The idea is fine and it very nearly works...I would say that it's a 'shade' too minimal. The temptation would be to create a lighting source that shows a little more of the inside right side of the neck to give more depth. and substance to the jar.

Love the concept,but tend to agree with Roger.....Not quite there, though very nearly. I think if it were mine I would add a light source on the left as you look at it mimicking the vase shape..... Though it's your pic and really rather beautiful.