Greenday

Welcome to the forum.

Here you can discuss all things art with like-minded artists, join regular painting challenges, ask questions, buy and sell art materials and much more.

Make sure you sign in or register to join the discussions.

Hang on Studio Wall
Message
Considering the battle I’ve had with this it didn’t turn out so badly. A few lessons along the way. Watercolour on cartridge.

Edited
by Brett Hill

Brett as you've put this in the critique section, are you looking for anything specific to be commented on , or general comments? 
Watercolour on cartridge can be a chancy affair - unless it's very robust cartridge, it can bubble up, buckle, and absorb the  paint.  On the other hand, it can provide a lovely smooth surface, receptive to light washes - it all depends on the weight of the paper.  I like this painting, and wonder how it would look on, say, hot-pressed watercolour paper: more robust, but just as smooth.   Anyway, it's looking  fine to  me  as it is.
Brett as you've put this in the critique section, are you looking for anything specific to be commented on , or general comments? 
Gerry Mellor on 07/02/2026 18:30:07 I’m happy to hear comments specific or general. Or to hear of others experiences. Conversation is a great thing.
Watercolour on cartridge can be a chancy affair - unless it's very robust cartridge, it can bubble up, buckle, and absorb the  paint.  On the other hand, it can provide a lovely smooth surface, receptive to light washes - it all depends on the weight of the paper.  I like this painting, and wonder how it would look on, say, hot-pressed watercolour paper: more robust, but just as smooth.   Anyway, it's looking  fine to  me  as it is.
Robert Jones, Napa on 07/02/2026 19:02:38 I’ll be buying some new paper in a few days. Cartridge is not the best but it’s all I had at the time, so I’m looking forward to working on better paper.
Decent watercolour paper is an essential part of your painting kit , you can get away wit reasonable quality paint, brushes etc, but get the best paper you can . Quality paper holds the paint and the surface aids the look of the finished piece. Always buy the best quality of paint, brushes that are within you budget , good well made equipment lasts longer , holds the paint better . I   initially started with just a couple of brushes but decent ones , have built up a collection overt the years but to be honest you don’t need all the fancy brushes etc that are marketed. Best quality paper always a must . 
If you’re painting on lightweight paper, including watercolour paper, expect it to cockle when you apply a wash - this goes for 90lb and even 140lb weight, it just can’t handle heavy washes. When it dries out, it will still be cockled… that’s what happens and is unavoidable! I use 300lb for my finished watercolours, but it isn’t necessary to go up to that weight when you’re first starting out! Try something like Bockingford 200lb, it’s a decent enough paper (not a particular favourite of mine), and in fact was used by Edward Wesson, so say no more! My preferred choice is either Arches or Fabriano, albeit I have been using Two Rivers NOT handmade stuff recently, fabulous quality! You don’t need lots of brushes - I use Sceptre by W&N, great quality as well as Daler D99 range… red handles with white tip. A size 8 or 10 for washes, a size 6 and a rigger, although the latter isn’t essential if you aren’t finishing off with detail. And lastly, 6 watercolours is plenty…pans or tubes -  learn to mix!
I did the exact same thing at the beginning when I started (or rather, started again) with watercolors. I bought the smallest size of Van Gogh paints (6 pieces) and started painting on cheap printer paper. The splashes were actually quite beautiful, but what I hadn't considered was: the amount of water the paper can absorb, the amount of pigment it can handle—it's a completely different feel for your hand, and a different sensory and perception. I hope I can explain what I mean; it's difficult for me. It's—to put it very dramatically—like painting on stone and then being surprised when you have a good piece of paper and paint on it. It's as if you have to learn everything all over again... you learn to paint on bad paper and then essentially have to relearn how to paint on good paper. I hope someone understands me...sorry, it's not my native language...you can also buy small, good-quality formats for practice (Fabriano = good quality, reasonably priced), postcard size or something similar, for practicing and testing...have fun
Tanja, you are making perfect  sense, don't worry about that!   
Thanks for all your comments. I only just remembered I’d put something up for critique. I have since been using watercolour paper and of course the results are as expected.