Painting knives vs palette knives

Welcome to the forum.

Here you can discuss all things art with like-minded artists, join regular painting challenges, ask questions, buy and sell art materials and much more.

Make sure you sign in or register to join the discussions.

Hang on Studio Wall
Showing page 2 of 2
Message
Bobbie - eternal experiment!  Edges of credit cards have innumerable uses, and not only in watercolour and acrylic; they're excellent for scraping out, and shaping colour: I wonder sometimes what we ever did without them; then we have matches, cocktail sticks, colour shapers, bits of dowelling - there's no end to what we can use to make marks. I was interested in your comment about the Bob Ross knife - I've not used one, I just thought the shape was useful: there are other makers of these chisel-type knives you might find better suited to you - in theory they should work well, but theory yields to practice ... that's a very useful point, from your personal experience.  God knows, there's very little else I can recommend from the Ross stable!  I'm sure he never understood how much damage he did to the mastery of painting technique: worked for him (he thought) so why not share it?  Anyway - I don't want to wriggle down THAT rabbit-hole again any sooner than I have to. 
Hmm… not to dwell on our friend Bob, but I don’t like the look of that ‘putty knife’ he uses… I can’t see any point in it, and it makes damned hard work of painting, when an appropriate sized brush would do a better job! He shapes his dreadful log cabins using nothing else, god they’re awful and his thick trademark fence posts using one of the edges!
Oh look!  A rabbit-hole!  Down I go...... I looked for what I could find from Ross's videos which would be of any use at all: I looked on the Bob Ross Inc website (which fairness demands I point out never had anything to do with him).  The easel - looked sturdy enough: but not cheap, and there are better ones out there; the brushes - fine if you were smoothing plaster, or repainting the kitchen; the paint - awful; just awful glutinous gobbets of gunk; the palette - transparent ... a good size, but do you want to be able to see through your palette?  How do you judge colour?   So - the knife; OK, maybe the knife.... yes, I could see a use for the knife; well, specifically, one use - making horizontal marks, drawing lines in paint and with paint.   Further thought, occasioned by Bobbie and Alan, prompts the question - why?  Why, and how often, would you WANT to paint long or short horizontals, and wouldn't a chisel-edge on a flat brush do the job just as well if not better?  And now I learn that the implement is a clumsy lump of plastic in the hand, my previous mild advocacy of it is exposed, to the world, as egregious error! To summarize, then: Bob Ross couldn't draw: his grasp of perspective wobbled like a jelly in an earthquake; and the Bob Ross products are every bit as bad as he was - but I go to one of my favourite art supply websites and there they are, masquerading as professional, or at least as serious, products for artists: and those who don't know any better, which appears to be characteristic of the people who supply them, get taken in.  Just don't be: now I know that the one product in which I invested any hope at all is actually verging on useless I can happily condemn the entire range - something very few other ranges entirely deserve, though some come close.  And of those - unless they leave a substantial sum in the old blasted oak, I shall name names....  
Apparently, Bob Ross used a converted aluminium stepladder as an easel in his tv series. Take a look… that’s exactly what it is, crude and amateur is the word here, and it shows in his work! He still has two half-hour slots running daily on channel 4 in the early evening, he has about six compositions in his armoury which he uses and makes variations on the same theme…ie… log cabin in almost every one, stippled fir trees, twee little mountain stream, with waterfall occasionally…snow capped mountains, stippled foliage of horrendous greens…very occasionally a moonlight seascape with that same unnatural wave every time - need I go on? because I could, but in the interests of art, I won’t! What would I give for just one half-hour slot a week, I’m not greedy - and demonstrate how to paint landscapes in oils, the traditional way and keeping well clear of ‘pretty’ pictures and ‘happy trees’…

Edited
by Alan Bickley

I'd watch you!  I'm sure many would - but TV loves trash.
I just use these two things - one to mix paint with (and occasionally put on the canvas but I'm not good at painting with a palette knife) and one to clean my palette - an oven glass scraper/cleaner thing - great for cleaning glass palettes. I should change the blade a little more often though 😂.
Showing page 2 of 2