"Van Gogh painted with thin bamboo sticks..." - NOT.

Welcome to the forum.

Here you can discuss all things art with like-minded artists, join regular painting challenges, ask questions, buy and sell art materials and much more.

Make sure you sign in or register to join the discussions.

Hang on Studio Wall
Message
As I might have mentioned before, I do quite a lot of trawling on YouTube and Facebook of arty sites and pages.  Some of these are good - though a warning: they can also take you a long way down the primrose path of reading about painting rather than actually doing any. Some comments on them, though, take bat-wittery to whole new levels of absurdity.  As in a comment suggesting that Vincent van Gogh used thin bamboo sticks to paint, specifically, "Starry Night".  This, the contributor suggested, was how he got those swirling strokes.  Even a cursory examination of Vincent's methods would have revealed that in this painting, he used a combination of bristle flats and filberts, plus a painting knife.  Would you like to try using thin bamboo sticks to replicate it?  I wouldn't! I doubt that anyone on POL would be misguided and misled enough to believe something as daft as this: what happened, I wonder - did the writer read that VvG used bamboo sticks (and reed and bamboo pens) for his works in ink and watercolour, and then assume he used them for oils as well?  Had he even given thought to the practicality of that - presuming, as he claims, he's a painter himself? Well I don't know, you won't know, so we can mark that question down as rhetorical.  But the thing is, no one challenged him, until I gently asked him if he had a source for this gem ... I tend to do this; if I see toe-curlingly bad advice, I challenge it.  Is the more sensible course of action, though, just to chuckle to oneself and pass on, without comment .... certainly, it makes for a more peacable life.  Fact is, I can't keep my trap shut in these circumstances - I have a horror of inexperienced painters taking such advice as gospel, and in this case scratching away with bits of  bamboo, wondering what's wrong with them that they can't make it work .. then again, if they're that dim, maybe they're beyond human help.... So what would you do?  I can guess what some would do; they'd stay well away from social media like YouTube, Facebook etc; but I insist, against all odds, that there IS some good stuff on both - even though idiocy can always break through; and to prove it: does.  
I keep well clear of social media platforms, some people enjoy them, but I’m not one of them. Actually, I’m too busy drawing and painting, or doing the mundane chores that one has to do daily! Proof, if any was needed, that a good proportion of the information out there is total b*******, and that’s official, because I’ve said it! Van Gogh is an artist that I greatly admire, and I’ve done a lot of research on him over the years, college years included. Of course he never ever (as far as is recorded), painted with bamboo sticks! He used his hands and fingers as we all know, I use my fingers a lot also, not for applying the paint, but adjusting and blending in etc…

Edited
by Alan Bickley

I also steer clear of social media sites, too much dross and foul content from what one reads.  I have read the book of Vincent’s letters to and fro with his brother Theo which includes endless lists of paints etc he required Theo to send. I don’t recall a single request “please don’t forget the bamboo sticks”!, Madness, presumably an idea conjured up by someone who doesn’t paint in any fashion.
Mind you, I can see where the person got it from and mixed things up.  Some Sothebys experts say Starry Night was inspired by the Hokusai's The Wave, during his Japanese period.  A reed pen is mentioned here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/culture/article/20180611-van-gogh-and-japan-the-prints-that-shaped-the-artist

Edited
by Norrette Moore

I can understand a reed pen for ink etc, I use one myself -